Journal
The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn Book Review: My Favorite Romance
I read The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn by Valerie Bowman earlier this fall, and I absolutely loved it. It stands as my favorite romance novel to date.
Here is my honest The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn book review, no spoilers, plus the bookmark I paired it with.
The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn at a Glance
- Author: Valerie Bowman
- Series: Honeycrisp Orchard Romance, book one
- Published: September 2025
- Setting: a farmhouse inn on an apple orchard on Long Island, in the fall
- Tropes: forced proximity, hometown return, small town
- Spice: a few spicy scenes, just right for me
- Best read: September and October, with the apples in
- My rating: 5 out of 5 stars
What The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn Is About
Ellie is an event planner with a big corporate career in Manhattan. When her life in the city falls apart, she comes home to Long Island, where her parents run a charming inn on an apple orchard owned by their lifelong best friends. The inn is getting ready for the Harvest Festival, and Ellie is there to help.
The catch: she has to share the inn’s attic apartment with Aiden, the orchard owners’ son, whom she hasn’t really seen since they were kids. Then their parents put the two of them in charge of the festival together, and the festival is what both the orchard and the inn are counting on to get through the year.
Two people stuck under one roof and working side by side, on an orchard in the fall. It is the kind of setup that does a lot of the work for you, and this book makes the most of it.
My Honeycrisp Orchard Inn Review
My rating: 5 out of 5 stars.
The chemistry
There was strong chemistry between the two main characters. Being thrown together, sharing a home and a job, only made it better.
Ellie
I loved the female lead, Ellie. I love her persona, her expressions, and her style as described in the book. She was very relatable, sweet, funny, and charming.
The setting
The setting was dreamy: an apple orchard with a farmhouse inn. I loved the crisp fall weather, the decor on the farm and at the festival, the homes and their interior decorating, and the outfits.

The themes
I loved the themes of social media and event planning, and Ellie deciding between staying in her corporate event planning career or going back home, where she rediscovers her love for being around her family and the hometown she grew up in.
The ending
The way the story ended was perfect. I wish there were a sequel about Ellie and Aiden. It is the type of story I would love to see as a movie.
Is The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn Spicy?
The spicy scenes were just right, and they reinforced the chemistry between Ellie and Aiden.
Who Will Love This Book
- Anyone who loves a small-town fall romance with a strong love story at its heart.
- Readers who like a “stuck under one roof” story, also called forced proximity.
- Anyone who has ever thought about leaving the city and going home again.
What to Read After The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn
If you loved this one, you might also enjoy Lovelight Farms, a friends-to-lovers Christmas tree farm romance I reviewed here. It is the natural next step once the leaves are down and the first frost comes in. The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn is also on my holiday reading list, along with five more cozy fall and Christmas books.
A Bookmark to Match
On my reading list, I paired this one with the autumn leaf bookmark from The Cottage Bookmarks: leaves, pumpkins, and acorns in soft watercolor gingham. It suits an orchard in the fall.
They print three to a page at home on matte cardstock or matte photo paper. Trim them by hand along the dashed lines with a paper trimmer, or let your Cricut cut them with the included Print Then Cut files. My Cricut guide walks through it step by step. If you would like to try one first, The Cozy Winter Gingham Bookmark Set is free.
Have you read The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn? I would love to know if it became one of your favorites too.
Common questions
What tropes are in The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn?
Forced proximity is the big one: Ellie and Aiden end up sharing the inn's attic apartment and running the Harvest Festival together. It is also a hometown-return story, with two people who knew each other as kids, set in a small town in the fall.
What is The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn about?
Ellie, a Manhattan event planner, comes home to her family's inn on an apple orchard to help it get ready for the harvest festival. She ends up sharing the inn's attic apartment with Aiden, the son of the orchard's owner, and the two of them are put in charge of the festival together. It is a cozy fall romance about finding your way back home.
Is The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn spicy?
There are spicy scenes, and for me they were just right. Most of the book is about the chemistry between the two leads, the orchard, and the family and hometown Ellie comes back to.
Is The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn part of a series?
Yes. It is the first book in Valerie Bowman's Honeycrisp Orchard Romance series. The second book, Snowed Inn, is a Christmas story set at the same inn.
When is the best time to read The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn?
Early to mid fall, when the apples are in and the leaves are turning. The story builds toward the harvest festival, so it reads beautifully in September and October.