Journal
My Holiday Reading List: Cozy Fall and Christmas Books
Every year, somewhere between the first cold morning and the first snow, I start keeping a little stack of books by my chair. Nothing heavy. Small towns, warm cafés, Christmas tree lots, and people finding their way home. These are the books I reach for when the evenings get dark early and the tea is still hot.
This is my holiday reading list for fall and winter — six cozy books that carry me from pumpkins to snow, and the bookmarks I have tucked inside each one.
Cozy Fall Books for the Start of the Season
I like to begin with autumn while it is still autumn outside. Orchards, harvest festivals, and pumpkin everything. These two are the ones I read first.
1. The Pumpkin Spice Café by Laurie Gilmore
Jeanie inherits her aunt’s café in the little town of Dream Harbor and leaves her city life behind to run it — with a grumpy local farmer, Logan, never far away. It is the first book in the Dream Harbor series, and it reads exactly like its title: warm, sweet, and very much a fall book.
A spice note: this one is open door, with a few explicit scenes in the second half.
Tucked inside: the pumpkin bookmark from The Cottage Bookmarks. It felt only right.

2. The Honeycrisp Orchard Inn by Valerie Bowman
Ellie arrives at an inn on an apple orchard hoping for a quiet place to land, and finds the orchard owner’s stubborn son, Aiden, already living in the attic apartment she had planned on. Then the two of them are put in charge of the Harvest Festival together. Apples, an old inn, and a whole town getting ready for fall — this is the book I want on a gray October afternoon.
Tucked inside: the autumn leaf bookmark from The Cottage Bookmarks.

Christmas Books to Read Through December
Once the Thanksgiving table is set and cleared, I switch to Christmas. These four are my December books, and I try to save the last one for the week before Christmas.
3. The Twelve Dates of Christmas by Jenny Bayliss
Kate signs up for a dating agency’s Twelve Dates of Christmas — twelve dates, twelve different men, all in the run-up to the holiday. It is funny and warm, full of village Christmas traditions, and a perfect early-December read when the lights are just going up.
Tucked inside: the red bow bookmark from The Christmas Bookmarks.
4. Bright Lights, Big Christmas by Mary Kay Andrews
Kerry Tolliver drives her family’s Christmas trees from their farm all the way to New York City, where they sell them from a corner stand in Greenwich Village — and she spends the season living in a tiny vintage camper with her brother. Fraser firs, city lights, and a Christmas tree lot as the heart of the story. If you love the smell of a real tree, this one is for you.
Tucked inside: the snowflake bookmark from The Christmas Bookmarks, forest green gingham like a fir tree.
5. Evergreen Christmas by Janet Dailey
Jordyn Banks, a barrel racer who has never really had a place to call home, finds land for sale in the little town of Noel, North Carolina — just right for raising her horses. Noel is a Christmas town through and through, with a holiday competition underway and a neighbor, Nate, who may or may not be ready to open his heart again. It is the first book in the Frosted Firs Ranch series, and it reads like a Christmas movie you curl up with on a snowy night.
Tucked inside: the red-and-green Christmas plaid from The Cozy Winter Gingham Bookmark Set, my free set. Plaid felt right for a ranch.
6. The Spiced Cocoa Café by Harper Graham
The second book in the Maple Falls series, after The Cinnamon Spice Inn. Cassidy runs a chocolate shop, and her rival, Liam, is not making her Christmas season any easier. Chocolate, a small town in winter, and a café you will wish was real. I save this one for the very last days before Christmas, with a mug of cocoa beside me.
A spice note: the Maple Falls books are steamy, open-door romances.
Tucked inside: the gingerbread bookmark from The Christmas Bookmarks.
A Bookmark for Every Book on the List
Half the fun of a seasonal reading list, for me, is the little things that go with it. A blanket, a candle, and a bookmark that matches the season. I printed both of our bookmark sets at home this fall, one page each, three bookmarks to a page.

- The Cottage Bookmarks — autumn leaves, pumpkins, and acorns in soft watercolor gingham. For the fall half of the list.
- The Christmas Bookmarks — red bows, gingerbread, and snowflakes on gingham. For the December books.
- The Cozy Winter Gingham Bookmark Set — a free set of four in berry, forest, and sage. Simple enough for any book, any time of year.
You can trim them by hand with a paper trimmer along the dashed lines, then round the corners if you like. The two illustrated sets also come with Cricut Print Then Cut files — if you have never tried Print Then Cut, I walk through it step by step in my Cricut guide. Print on matte cardstock or matte photo paper for the richest color.
Gifting Your Holiday Reading List
If there is a reader on your Christmas list, one of these books with a matching bookmark tucked inside makes a lovely, simple gift. Wrap the book in brown paper, tie it with ribbon, and let the bookmark peek out of the top. Or print a full set of bookmarks and slip three into a Christmas card for a friend from your book club.
What’s On Your List?
That is my stack for this season — two for autumn, four for Christmas. I would love to know what you are reading this year. If you want a little more of this, the Reading Room is my monthly letter, with seasonal making ideas, new printables, and the books I am loving. You can join below.
Happy reading, friend.
Common questions
What makes a book a cozy fall read?
A cozy fall book usually has a small-town setting, a slower pace, and the season woven right into the story — orchards, harvest festivals, cafés, and the first cold mornings. Nothing too heavy. It should feel like the book version of a warm drink.
When should I start reading Christmas books?
I start mine in November, once the Thanksgiving table is planned. That leaves time for one or two autumn books first, then the Christmas stories through December, so the season unfolds slowly instead of all at once.
What is a good small gift for a book lover at Christmas?
A book they have been wanting, with a handmade bookmark tucked inside. Printable bookmarks are an easy way to do it — print them at home on matte cardstock or matte photo paper, trim them, and tie a few with ribbon or slip one into a Christmas card.
Can I make bookmarks at home without a Cricut?
Yes. Our printable bookmarks have light dashed lines along each edge, so a paper trimmer or sharp scissors is all you need. The paid sets also include Cricut Print Then Cut files if you would rather let the machine do the cutting.